Electroless nickel immersion gold (ENIG) has captured the major share of the lead free final finish market globally even though it’s not the least expensive. ENIG not only provides a robust metallic
coating required for assembly with lead free alloys,but also,an effective barrier to virtually stop copper migration into the attachment surface of the PCB. This provides a true surface with long term,low contact resistance with long shelf life and good solderability. So why make any changes to ENIG?
Three reasons;
• Improved window on lead free soldering
• Improved robustness for touch contacts.
• Wire bonding of fine features
Lead Free Soldering: After years of testing,discussions,failures and success,lead free soldering has completed the transition from the lab to production. Lead while bad for the environment,was great for soldering and had a tremendous operating window. When compared to eutectic tin lead,liquidous time and spreadability of lead free alloys is less making the final finish on the PCB more critical. As far as ENIG,imperfections in the ENIG deposit,which were not critical with eutectic tin lead,can become an issue because the operating window on Pb-free soldering processes are tighter.
Soldering actually occurs on the electroless nickel as the immersion gold is dissolved into the solder joint. Oxides or intermetallics on the electroless nickel decrease the solderability of the electroless
nickel surface causing poor solder wetting or weak solder joints. The oxides and intermetallics are actually corrosion products from the deposition of immersion gold on the electroless nickel. With
eutectic tin lead this was called black pad and as suppliers we have learned to reduce the aggressiveness of the immersion gold by shorter times or chemical changes and to increase the chemical resistance of the electroless nickel by increasing the phosphorus content and selection of stabilizers. Classic black pad was a major issue with eutectic solder,but minor amounts of corrosion products typically soldered fine. Now with reduced wetting from lead free soldering,the amount of corrosion products that can be
tolerated is reduced.
These corrosion products can be observed under the immersion gold by stripping the gold and evaluating the surface below. A few things become evident in the location and formation of the
corrosion products. They almost always initiate around the electroless nickel grain boundaries and or in areas where the electroless nickel coverage is not complete,like around micro-pits or edges of traces or around pads. When cross-sectioned,if due to imperfections in the electroless nickel deposit,large corrosion spikes can be seen at relatively low power. These areas while extremely small would still solder completely with eutectic tin lead and with most lead free soldering processes. The exception is a
lead free process with extremely short liquidious time. This provides less wetting time to penetrate the corrosion products.