A Novel Approach to Evaluate the Impact on Solder Joint Reliability due to Multiple BGA Rework

Member Download (pdf)

PCB assemblies with numerous BGAs often go through multiple BGA reworks but there is not much data to suggest its effect
on the long term solder joint reliability of the BGAs. This study is focused in addressing this gap and to provide a
recommendation for the number of BGA reworks that could be performed without any impact to solder reliability.
To prepare a test unit for evaluating BGA solder joint reliability after multiple reworks,many BGAs are required for the
multiple detaching / attaching process. This traditional method is labor intensive and expensive. A novel method for test unit
preparation of multiply reworked BGA is explored here. In this method,instead of detaching an old and replacing a new
BGA,the same BGA unit was reflowed on the assembly multiple times to mimic the thermal excursion cycles. In the last
rework cycle,a new BGA replaces the old one that has been reflowed multiple times. The validity of the novel method was
explored by comparing the solder joint microstructures obtained by the traditional and novel methods. The interfacial
intermetallic layers,resulting from both the traditional and novel methods using identical temperature profiles and after up to
5 rework cycles,had comparable intermetallic thickness and porous microstructure. In the unit prepared with the novel
method,the intermetallic layer became thicker and denser as rework cycles progressed,but after the last rework cycle in
which a new BGA was added,the intermetallic layer became thinner and porous.
Using the novel method,two different BGA packages were chosen,9x15mm CSP and 45mm FCBGA,to study both small
and large package designs. Solder joint reliability was evaluated by performing Accelerated Thermal Cycling (ATC) and
mechanical shock testing on the as-assembled controls,3 and 5 reworked samples. Test results showed that there was no
impact to solder joint reliability due to multiple BGA reworks.

Author(s)
Bala Nandagopal,Zequn Mei,Sue Teng,Mason Hu
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2006

Lead Free BGA Rework: A comparison of the effect on reliability of reworked BGAs that have been processed with solder paste printing or flux only attachment

Member Download (pdf)

The use of the Area Array Package and in particular,Ball Grid Array (BGA) technology in the electronics industry continues
to increase due to the fact that this package type allows for a greater I/O count in a smaller area while maintaining a pitch that
allows for ease of manufacture. The original assembly process,and to a large extent the rework process for BGA devices
utilizing tin/lead solder materials,has proven to be fairly trouble-free. Environmental and legislative concerns are forcing
many manufacturing facilities to transition to Lead Free materials and processes that don’t have the same long history of use
as tin/lead products.
It is now common knowledge that Lead Free solder will exhibit reduced wetting when compared to traditional tin/lead
solders. As more and more assemblies are transitioned to Lead Free materials,it is important to understand what impact the
variables of solder wetting will have on the reliability of these Lead Free assemblies. What effects will a “flux only”
attachment of the BGA have on the wetting characteristics? What about paste print volume or the size and shape of the
stencil apertures?
This paper will review the results of thermal cycling of BGA samples that were processed with Lead Free materials utilizing
different solder paste print parameters,flux attachment only,and different BGA land pattern diameters. The goal will be to
use the resulting correlations to develop guidelines for the best reliability of reworked BGA devices.

Author(s)
Ray Cirimele
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2006

Single Ball Reballing and Repair of BGA Components

Member Download (pdf)

The trend of increasing complication in the rework arena continues. Sources of today’s rework challenges include the
development of smaller and smaller components and the continued difficulty of reworking BGAs (with defective,deformed,
or missing balls). Add to that,the necessity for contract manufacturers to have a reliable solution to reduce waste continues.
The need exists to blend “typical” rework (SMD components,lead-free solder and 0201) with more complex rework,such as
single ball reballing. Or,simply put,to reuse BGA components that have failed capillarity tests or have arrived from the
manufacturer as defective parts.

Author(s)
Robert V. Avila
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2006

The Effect of Processing,Glass Finish,and Rheology on the Interlaminar Shear Strength of a Woven e-Glass Reinforced Polymer Matrix Composite

Member Download (pdf)

Laminated woven glass reinforced polymer matrix composites (PMC) are commonly used in the electronics industry as a
robust and effective substrate for circuit boards. In such applications,reliability is extremely important. The laminated
composites must undergo several processing steps to introduce circuitry,during which interlaminar damage is sometimes
introduced,leading to blisters and delaminations. Therefore,it becomes important to understand the factors that control the
interlaminar shear strength (ILSS) of the laminate. In this study,the ILSS of a laminated PMC was examined as functions of
matrix phase additions,the matrix mixing procedure,the glass fiber finish chemistry and concentration,and the matrix
rheology. Matrix phase additions,mixing,and glass finish were found to significantly effect the ILSS,while the matrix
rheology had less of an impact.

Author(s)
George B. Piotrowski,Marty Choate,Scott Lucas
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2006

Novel Toughening Agents for Thermosetting Systems for PWB Base Materials

Member Download (pdf)

The proposed revision of IPC 4101 - Specification for Base Materials for Rigid and Multilayer Printed Boards contains
new slash sheets describing FR-4 base materials compatible with lead-free assembly. These specification sheets also
outline requirements not found currently for FR-4 including Td,T260 and T288. In order to achieve minimum
performance criteria,toughening agents have been incorporated into the FR-4 resin systems both for 135 and 170°C
materials. Current modifiers for toughening thermosetting systems exhibit significant drawbacks including depression
of the glass transition temperature,instability of the formulation and difficulty of use. Core Shell Rubber (CSR)
particles have been used successfully for more than 40 years in thermoplastic applications but have had limited success
in thermosetting systems due to difficulty in dispersing the solid powder into the resin system.
We have developed a proprietary process for dispersing CSR domains into various thermosetting resins. The CSR
particles are perfectly dispersed and remain so during storage under a variety of conditions and after the formulating
process is complete. The resulting FR-4 composite exhibits improved inter-laminar adhesion,fracture toughness and
lap shear strength without depressing the glass transition temperature or other thermal properties related to the cross
link density. The CSR particles are supplied as a 25% concentrate in an epoxy resin chosen by the formulator such as
a liquid Bis-A or multifunctional brominated epoxy thus minimizing initial development work.
This paper will discuss the merits and use of these novel toughening agents for thermosetting systems for lead-free
compatible base materials.

Author(s)
Riichi Nishimura,Douglas J. Sober,Mike Miyamoto
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2006

Thin and Elastic Substrates for Ultrathin Multilayer Boards

Member Download (pdf)

New substrates for ultrathin multilayer boards consist of ultrathin glass fabric and a novel low elastic modulus thermosetting
resin system. They are composed of various lineups with the same resin system for the first time in the world; laminate
(TC-C-100),prepreg (TC-P-100),resin-coated copper (TC-F-100),adhesive resin film (TC-A-100). By using these lineups,
it is possible to fabricate a variety of thin multilayer PWB. In particular,with TC-C-100 and TC-F-100,you can easily
fabricate a bendable part and a multilayer part in a unity. Since the cover-layer and the bonding sheet are unnecessary,you
can make thinner PWB of higher density. In addition,they will make the circuit manufacturing process simpler to provide
thinner and bendable multilayer PWB with higher reliability.

Author(s)
Nozomu Takano,Toshiyuki Iijima,Masashi Tanaka,Yoshitsugu Matsuura
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2006

Dielectric Constant and Dissapation Factor of Fr4 Laminates Produced Using Specific Vendors of Fiberglass Yarn

Member Download (pdf)

Currently there is not a specification within the IPC for the DK and DF of E-Glass reinforcements and there is no
requirement to report the DK and DF of the glass formulation used to produce E-glass yarn. Without a specification,
performance of reinforced PWB substrates can be subject to significant variation depending on the supplier of the fiberglass
cloth. In an effort to understand the impact on the electrical performance of PWB substrate materials related to the choice of
fiberglass yarn manufacturer,FR4 laminates were produced using fiberglass cloth woven with yarns from specific vendors
and tested for their dielectric performance.

Author(s)
William Varnell,Helen Enzien,Robert Duga
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2006

A Comparison of Small Discretes and Polymer Thick Film Embedded Resistors for Mobile Phone Applications

Member Download (pdf)

As an increasing amount of functionality is crammed into today's mobile phones,designers must find ways to save
board area. Two common solutions are the use of embedded passives and the use of smaller (0201) discretes. In
this paper,we examine the cost and area tradeoffs between small discretes and embedded polymer thick resistors.
Three typical mobile phone designs are analyzed using high volume assembly and state of the art board fabrication
techniques for scenarios with either small discretes or polymer thick film (PTF) resistors. The size and cost impacts
of each option are presented.

Author(s)
Chet Palesko,Tero Karkäinen
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2006

S0201 Process and Yield Improvement During Launch to Production

Member Download (pdf)

Part miniaturization is inevitable in surface mount assembly. With each shift to smaller component types,new critical process
parameters emerge and old process parameters become significantly more important. New failure modes emerge and
challenge the manufacturing engineer to adapt existing equipment and design parameters to maximize yield as assemblies
incorporating these miniature components are introduced to current manufacturing processes.
The use of 0201 passive components has significant advantages for PCB designers; part density can be increased and PCB
size can be decreased. In conjunction with incorporating 0201 passive components,microBGA components also are
attractive complements in achieving these goals. However,careful consideration of land layout,surface finish,and solder
stencil apertures must be undertaken to ensure high yield assembly. The manufacturing engineer must ensure that proper
stencil materials and fabrication processes are specified. Existing board support methods must be examined and strategies
modified or improved. Equipment must be examined for the capability to process miniature components. Additional tooling
may be required for both handling and placement of miniature components. Non-standard programming techniques may be
required to increase component handling rates and placement yield.

Author(s)
Jason Fullerton
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2006

PCB Design and Assembly Process Development of 01005 Components with Lead Free Solder

Member Download (pdf)

The continuing demand for smaller,lighter multifunctional portable electronic products has driven the use of miniature
components. To satisfy this demand,01005 chip components are now commercially available. However the implementation
for such tiny components into new products presents some design and assembly process challenges. In this study,a test
vehicle was designed to investigate the effect of PCB pad design on assembly yield. Process capability of the 01005 test
board manufacturing was evaluated. A Design of Experiments (DOE) was used to optimize the solder paste printing based on
3D solder paste inspection. Lead free solder was used for all assembly trials. Several tests were performed to explore the
influences of process parameters on placement accuracy and reflow defects. Through the analysis of experimental results and
post-reflow inspection for assembly defects,recommendations for PCB design and assembly processes are made.

Author(s)
Yueli Liu,Shaunte Rodgers,R. Wayne Johnson
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2006