Whether based on good science or not,the elimination of lead from electronic equipment as a result of the European RoHS
legislation is a reality. Even those market segments with exemptions meant to last several years are being pushed towards
Lead Free assembly sooner than expected due to component availability concerns and constraints within the electronics
manufacturing services industry. The most common question asked of base material suppliers is ‘what laminate can I use?’
From the standpoint of ‘compliance,’ most laminate materials are acceptable. Most materials do not contain lead or the other
restricted metals. The brominated flame retardant used in most laminates is NOT restricted either. However,in terms of
‘compatibility,’ the answer is very complex. This is the result of several factors. First,PWB design and construction will
have a significant impact on the base material properties required. Thin,low layer count PWBs may have different
requirements than very thick,high layer count PWBs. Copper weights,aspect ratios and other design features will also have
an impact. End use application and the associated requirement for long-term reliability will also impact the decision-making
process. The requirements for a cell phone,video game or even a computer motherboard will be very different than those for
high-end servers,telecommunications gear,avionics,and critical medical and automotive electronics. Last,not all Lead Free
assembly processes are the same. Some designs will experience peak temperatures of 245oC while others will experience
peak temperatures of 260oC. Some PWBs may experience 2-3 thermal cycles,others up to 5-6,or even more depending on
how many reworks are allowed. All of this makes it impossible to recommend one base material for all applications without
either under specifying the laminate material and risking defects during assembly or later on in the field,or over specifying
the material and paying too much for the material or limiting availability. The purpose of this paper is to summarize the
critical laminate properties,present test data showing the impact of higher temperatures,and introduce a laminate material
selection approach designed to help answer the question regarding what laminate material should be considered for a given
application.
Author(s)
Ed Kelley,Erik Bergum,David Humby,Ron Hornsby,William Varnell