Reliability Assessment of No-clean and Water-soluble Solder Pastes Part II

Member Download (pdf)

Looking back twenty-five years ago,the solder pastes residues had to be cleaned after reflow due to their corrosive nature; two ways of cleaning were possible,either with solvent or by using water,with or without detergent. Now the assembly world is mainly no-clean: paste formulation is safer in terms of chemical reliability and process costs are reduced without cleaning. However,some applications,i.e. military,aerospace,high frequency,semiconductor require a perfect elimination of the residue after reflow. There are several options to achieve this result: the use of a no-clean paste which residue can be removed with the most suitable cleaning method or use the paste desiged to be cleaned,as a water soluble solder paste.
The water-soluble solder pastes generally show great wettability because of tehir strong activation but they are also known to have shorter stencil life and to be more sensitive to working conditions as temperature and humidity,compared to the no-clean pastes. Additionaly,with the components stad-off getting smaller and smaller,washing residues with water only is more and more challenging due to its high surface tension; the addition of detergent becomes often necessary.
The purpose of this paper is to highlight the differences between these two families of solder pastes to guide users in their choice. This will be achieved through the comparison of several recent water-soluble and no-clean formulations as far as reliability is concerned. First the printing quality will be evaluated (viscosity,tack,cold slump,printing speed according to pressure,stemcil life,idle time,printing consistency). Then the reflow properties will be compared (hot slump,solderballing,refow process window,wetting ability on different finishes). Finally the residue cleanibility will be assessed. The IPC SIR will be also done to conclude the study. Bth standardized tests and production tests will be used to evaluate the performance on these two kinds of solder pastes.

Author(s)
Emmanuelle Guéné
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

Reliability Assessment of No-clean and Water-soluble Solder Pastes Part II

Member Download (pdf)

Looking back twenty-five years ago,the solder pastes residues had to be cleaned after reflow due to their corrosive nature; two ways of cleaning were possible,either with solvent or by using water,with or without detergent. Now the assembly world is mainly no-clean: paste formulation is safer in terms of chemical reliability and process costs are reduced without cleaning. However,some applications,i.e. military,aerospace,high frequency,semiconductor require a perfect elimination of the residue after reflow. There are several options to achieve this result: the use of a no-clean paste which residue can be removed with the most suitable cleaning method or use the paste desiged to be cleaned,as a water soluble solder paste.
The water-soluble solder pastes generally show great wettability because of tehir strong activation but they are also known to have shorter stencil life and to be more sensitive to working conditions as temperature and humidity,compared to the no-clean pastes. Additionaly,with the components stad-off getting smaller and smaller,washing residues with water only is more and more challenging due to its high surface tension; the addition of detergent becomes often necessary.
The purpose of this paper is to highlight the differences between these two families of solder pastes to guide users in their choice. This will be achieved through the comparison of several recent water-soluble and no-clean formulations as far as reliability is concerned. First the printing quality will be evaluated (viscosity,tack,cold slump,printing speed according to pressure,stemcil life,idle time,printing consistency). Then the reflow properties will be compared (hot slump,solderballing,refow process window,wetting ability on different finishes). Finally the residue cleanibility will be assessed. The IPC SIR will be also done to conclude the study. Bth standardized tests and production tests will be used to evaluate the performance on these two kinds of solder pastes.

Author(s)
Emmanuelle Guéné
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

New Requirements for Sir- Measurement

Member Download (pdf)

During the last period of newly assembled electrical devices (pcbs),new component types like LGA and QFN were also qualified as well as smaller passive components with reliability requirements based on the automotive and industrial industry. In the narrow gaps under components,residues can accumulate more by the capillary forces. This is not that much a surface resistance than an interface issue. Also that the flux residues under such types of components creates interaction with the solder resists from the pcb,as well as the component body was not completely described in the standard SIR measurement. On the other hand also,electrical influence with higher voltage creates new terms and conditions,in particular the combination of power and logic in such devices. The standard SIR measurement cannot analyze those combinations. The paper will discuss the requirements for a measurement process,and will give results. The influences of the pcb and component quality will also be discussed. Furthermore it will describe requirements for nc solder paste to increase the chemical/thermical/electrical reliability for whole devices.

Author(s)
Jörg Trodler,Mathias Nowottnick
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

An Examination of Glass-fiber and Epoxy Interface Degradation in Printed Circuit Boards

Member Download (pdf)

Conductive filament formation or CAF typically occurs in two steps: degradation of the resin/glass fiber bond followed by an electrochemical reaction. Bond degradation provides a path along which electro-deposition occurs due to electrochemical reaction. The path results from poor glass treatment,from the hydrolysis of the silane glass finish,or from mechanical stresses. Once a path is formed,an aqueous layer can develop through the adsorption,absorption,and capillary action of moisture at the resin/fiber interface. The path can be modeled as an electrochemical cell,in which the metal conductors are the electrodes,the driving potential for the electrochemistry is the operating potential of the circuit,and the electrolyte is the absorbed moisture.
Microscopic examinations of failure sites have shown that conductive filaments can be formed along debonded or delaminated fiber glass/epoxy resin interfaces due to breaking of the organosilane bonds. The organosilane bonds can be chemically degraded by hydrolysis (adsorption of water at the fiber glass/epoxy resin interface) or by repeated thermal cycling,which induces stresses at the interface due to coefficient of thermal expansion mismatches. This paper discusses the formation of pathways due to the degradation of organosilanes.

Author(s)
Bhanu Sood,Michael Osterman,Michael Pecht
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

Printed Circuit Board Fabrication Processes and Their Effects on Fine Copper Barrel Cracks

Member Download (pdf)

The onset of copper barrel cracks is typically induced by the presence of manufacturing defects. In the absence of discernible manufacturing defects,the causes of copper barrel cracks in printed circuit board (PCB) plated through holes is not well understood. Accordingly,there is a need to determine what affects the onset of barrel cracks and then control those causes to mitigate their initiation.
The objective of this research is to conduct a design of experiment (DOE) to determine if there is a relationship between PCB fabrication processes and the prevalence of fine barrel cracks. The test vehicle used will be a 16-layer epoxy-based PCB that has two different sized plated through holes as well as buried vias.
The DOE will include an 8 run experiment with 2 center point runs for a total of 10 runs. This experimental setup is a half fractional factorial with resolution IV. Resolution IV means that main effects,each factor considered individually,are confounded with 3-way interactions. The PCB manufacturing processes selected as factors include laminate cooling rate,plating current density,pulse waveform,and hot air solder leveling (HASL) reflow. A confounded interaction cannot be separated out statistically from its “aliased” main effect. This DOE is a screening design,which is preferred for early investigation since the likelihood that a 3-way interaction would dominate over a main effect is extremely unlikely.
For this DOE,some deviations from an ideal experimentation setup are present. Since each coupon has multiple holes,samples are not uniquely independent. Also,the factors of pulse waveform and current density are not independent. The pulse waveform is also a nominal variable listed as a continuous factor for design purposes and has no center point value.

Author(s)
Edward Arthur,Charles Busa,Melissa Durfeem,Chad Gibson,Wade Goldman
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

An Experimental Approach to Characterising CAF

Member Download (pdf)

The electrochemical short,Conductive Anodic Filamentation,that that can develop within a PCB can be difficult to diagnose and detect,and there are many material and process issues that can lead to failure. Since the failure typically has a low incidence rate and typically occurs within multilayer boards identify the route-cause is challenging. NPL is developing a method for determining the sensitivity to various material and process factors that facilitate characterisation of these factors. Here we describe the first phase of the work where we have built a simple structure where we control the various materials and processes in building a PCB. In this simulation vehicle the resin,the glass fibres,the PTH characteristics are investigated,with various reflow processing to stress the structure. After damp heat testing with electrical bias CAF are formed,and since the simulation vehicle is thin it is easy to identify the CAF optically,in addition to the electrical measurements. The presented results will discuss the relative sensitivity to the material conditions and processing parameters within the simulation vehicle. For example the surface condition of glass fibres were found to be critical.

Author(s)
Christopher Hunt,Ling Zou
Resource Type
Slide Show
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

NanoCopper Based Solder-free Electronic Assembly Material

Member Download (pdf)

The Advanced Technology Center of the Lockheed Martin Corporation has developed a nanotechnology enabled copper-based electrical interconnect material that can be processed around 200 °C. The readily scalable Cu nanoparticles synthesis process uses a low cost solution-phase chemical reduction approach. A pilot plant is fully operational producing one lb per batch of nanomaterial. We have demonstrated assembly of fully functional LED test boards using a copper-nanoparticle paste with a consistency similar to standard solder. Further improvements have led to the assembly of a small camera board with a 48 pad CMOS sensor QFN chip and a 26 pin throughhole connector. In addition,we have a fully functional nanocopper assembly line in place for process development using standard industrial off-the shelf equipment. We are currently working with a commercial assembly house to dial-in the board assembly process. The fused material shows a tensile strength that is already in the range of space qualified solder. Once fully optimized,the nanocopper-based (trademarked CuantumFuseTM) solder-like material is expected to produce joints and interconnects with up to 10 times the electrical and thermal conductivity compared to tin-based solders currently in use and with a bond strength comparable or better than eutectic SnPb. Applications in space and commercial systems are currently under consideration.

Author(s)
A. A. Zinn,R. M. Stoltenberg,J. Beddow,J. Chang
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

Embedded Fibers Enhance Nano-Scale Interconnections

Member Download (pdf)

While the density of chip-to-chip and chip-to-package component interconnections increases and their size decreases the ease
of manufacture and the interconnection reliability are being reduced. This paper will introduce the use of embedded fibers in
the interconnections as a means of addressing these issues.
Flip chips bumps are evolving from large solder balls down to small thin copper pillars. Some copper pillars are solder capped and use a thermo-compression reflow attachment process. Smaller diameter copper pillars,while desirable by users,present a significant challenge to assemblers and reliability issues for end-users.
Nanostructures in the form of carbon nano-tubes have been evaluated for years. The recently created a means of growing metallic carbon nano-fibers,CNF's,to micro bumps which are solderable. When embedded with solder the fiber bumps produce robust component interconnections which can be less than 10 um in diameter and up to 20 um high. Attachment of the fiber micro bumps uses conventional thermo-compression bonding.
Results from the most recent evaluations will be presented indicating electrical performance and showing ease of manufacture resulting of such solder coated carbon nano-fiber micro bumps.

Author(s)
V. Desmarism,S. Shafiee,A. Saleem,A. Johansson,P. Marcoux
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

Lead-Free Nanosolder Based Nanomaterials Assembly and Integration

Member Download (pdf)

Nanomaterials have shown great promise in various applications including nanoelectronics and devices. However,in order to achieve large-scale nanoelectronics assembly and manufacturing,the development of smaller scale assembly and interconnection is necessary. More advanced nano-joining techniques are key enabling technologies in the construction of nanoelectronics and devices. In this presentation,we show that advanced nanosolder materials can be synthesized and developed for micro/nanoelectronics assembly and packaging applications. The nano-joining techniques are shown to be approached by utilizing nanosolders based on nanoparticles and nanowires. Both approaches are useful for the construction of different functional assemblies and nanodevices at the multi scales. The interactions between the nanosolders and substrates,including atomic diffusion,melting behavior and wetting property,are studied from both the one-dimensional and two-dimensional perspectives. The nano-joining techniques are also developed in consideration of the compatibility issue with the microelectronics assembly and packaging techniques.

Author(s)
Fan Gao,Zhiyong Gu,Sammy Shina
Resource Type
Slide Show
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014

A Robot’s Place in SMT

Member Download (pdf)

The SMT industry’s one constant is change. Standards are continually updated and components are miniaturized for space savings. In addition to the changes that come,the industry is also faced with continuing to deal with areas that fail to change and update. A typical PCB manufacturer lays out a line based on the need to put solder paste on a PCB,place parts in the paste,and then reflow the product (Figure 1). The board size,typical components placed,and the required speed for the line are then considered. Eventually a SMT manufacturing line is purchased that can handle a large majority of the process needs. In almost all cases,there will be a component that cannot be handled by the automated process currently in use on the factory floor. This is not a problem that is caused by the engineer who specified the line,nor is it the chosen vendor’s false advertising. This problem plagues virtually all PCB manufacturers because it is not cost effective to purchase a specialty machine to handle a component that is expected to go away and not be used any more,or the component that is thru-hole and was expected to be replaced by a SMT component soon. Manufacturers are expected to build as demanded and very often that demand is outside of the specifications which they thought were adequate,but the quantity does not justify new special equipment. PCB manufacturers,for example,face the
challenge of placing very large connectors,whose size is outside the specifications of SMT machines (Figure 2). Some manufacturers use thru-hole components in products (Figure 3),yet not enough need for this exists to justify a thru-hole machine.
Infrequently used components may fail to justify standard packaging for use,and oddly shaped parts may simply be beyond
the scope of what a standard SMT machine can handle. In addition to the difficulty in managing the changes in size and type
of component for placement,manufacturers must also consider the cost effectiveness of any solution they devise for managing these “out of spec.” placement issues. Rarely do these issues justify the expense of purchasing a specialty machine. Rather,the manufacturer finds it more cost effective and more realistic to manage these processes with human resources. These manufacturing difficulties are not caused by poor engineering design,or by the chosen vendor’s inattentiveness to customer needs. At the end of the day,manufacturers have come to accept that they will purchase a SMT line for the
manufacturing floor that is capable of handling a large percentage of their process needs,but those out of specification parts
will always exist.

Author(s)
Scott Zerkle,Makoto Murakami
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2014