Understanding the Effect of Different Heating Cycles on Post-Soldering Flux Residues and the Impact on Electrical Performance

Member Download (pdf)

There are several industry-accepted methods for determining the reliability of flux residues after assembly. The recommended methods of test sample preparation do not always closely mimic the thermal cycle experienced by an assembly. Therefore,extraction from actual assemblies has become a popular method of process control to assess consistency of post-reflow cleanliness. Every method of post-reflow flux residue characterization will depend on the reflow process followed to prepare the coupon. This investigation will focus on the effect of thermal conditions on the remainder of active ingredients in flux residues after assembly with no-clean solder pastes. Test coupons will be processed using an IR rework station with careful monitoring of thermal profile. In order to characterize the residues,IPC standard SIR testing will be conducted as well as localized extraction,followed by ion chromatography and IC/mass spec for detailed ionic and organic acid analysis. This will essentially characterize electrical reliability,while also quantifying chemical species present in the final assembly and hopefully the relationship between the two. Results will be presented to relate thermal profile to no-clean solder paste flux residues in SnPb and Pb-free processes.

Author(s)
Brook Sandy-Smith,Terry Munson
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2017

Using Condensation Testing with Surface Insulation Resistance Measurements for QFN Reliability Assessment

Member Download (pdf)

Quad Flat Non-lead (QFN) packages are finding increased uses in high reliability applications due to their smaller footprints,improved thermal and electrical performance [1] and as such there is increased focus on their reliability performance in harsh environments [2 to 5]. In order to investigate issues with condensation and surface insulation resistance (SIR),a range of test vehicles were assembled incorporating QFN components alongside other components,using two advanced production lines in Sweden. These boards were produced with multiple no-clean solder pastes using convection and vapour phase soldering. The aim of the project was to take surface insulation test boards based on the IPC B52 test pattern and assess the impact of conventional SIR testing of QFNs alongside a newly developed condensation test. This condensation test has been driven by an increased requirement to understand the performance of electronic assemblies in humid environments. Whenever there are high levels of ambient humidity,if parts of the assembly drop below the dew point,there is the opportunity for the formation of condensed water on the surface of components and substrate. This can significantly reduce the insulation resistance of the substrate surface,resulting in malfunctioning electronics. Reproducing repeatable levels of condensation during testing can be challenging. Most humidity chambers are designed to achieve stable,well controlled humidity and temperature conditions,but none of these offer condensing options. Therefore the user has to improvise. Existing common approaches include ramping at a fast enough rate to cause condensation,or running chambers very close to 100% relative humidity. A drawback of these approaches is that chambers of different designs will perform differently,and will be sensitive to small drops in cooling performance. At the company,a new approach has been developed where the test board is mounted on a platen whose temperature can be independently controlled without changing the ambient condition in the humidity chamber. Thus,the temperature of the test board can be lowered below ambient to any desired point and hence,produce different levels of condensation. It is therefore straightforward to cycle between condensing and non-condensing conditions on the test board in a constant ambient environment. The technique has been demonstrated to be repeatable and controllable,with the user able to select a temperature differential that matches their worst in-use conditions,or to understand the performance of their system under a range of condensing conditions. Modification of the test board in this project,allowed the group to test the impact of residues under the QFN/LGA packages with the introduction of SIR test patterns under four packages per board. There has been much debate on the reliability of the cleanliness under these packages and the possibility of surface corrosion. This work investigates the current uncertainty. This paper outlines the processes and parameters used for manufacture which featured surface mount reflow and through-hole selective soldering with no-clean fluxes. The results from the same boards with different paste products have been compared with testing under traditional exposure to elevated temperature and relatively humidity plus the controlled introduction of moisture to the test board.

Author(s)
Martin Wickham,Ling Zou,Bob Willis
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2017

Status and Outlooks of Flip Chip Technology

Member Download (pdf)

Status of flip chip technology such as wafer bumping,package substrate,flip chip assembly,and underfill will be reviewed in this study. Emphasis is placed on the latest developments of these areas in the past few years. Their future trends will also be recommended. Finally,the competition on flip chip technology will be briefly mentioned.

Author(s)
John H. Lau
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2017

Laser-Based Methodology for the Application of Glass as a Dielectric and Cu Pattern Carrier for Printed Circuit Boards

Member Download (pdf)

Glass offers a number of advantages as a dielectric material,such as a low coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE),high dimensional stability,high thermal conductivity and suitable dielectric constant. These properties make glass an ideal candidate for,among other things,package substrate and high-frequency PCB applications. We report here a novel process for the production of printed circuit boards and integrated circuit packaging using glass as both a dielectric medium and a platform for wiring simultaneously. An ultrafast laser is used to etch away the desired pattern (pads,wires and vias) in the glass,and copper plating is “seeded” through the laser-based deposition of copper droplets. The seeded area is then plated using electroless plating followed by electroplating. Demonstrations of fine pitch wires,variable diameter through holes and blind vias,and a multilayer stack are shown. The deposits have a resistivity less than a factor of 1.5x that of bulk copper for 5-10 mm wires. Plated lines in borosilicate glass of 7-10 µm width and 5-20 µm depth and line spacing down to ~10 µm are demonstrated,as well as vias with a top diameter approaching 100 µm for 150 µm thick glass and 40 µm for 50 µm thick glass. The process presents the potential for significant material savings in terms of base materials,process chemicals,and waste disposal/recycling costs (glass is on the order of 100-foldless expensive than some current high-frequency dielectrics,and wet processes account for a large part of standard PCB/substrate manufacturing). Additionally,the processes are amendable toward other dielectric materials such as FR4,PI,and PTFE-based materials.

Author(s)
Joel Schrauben,Cameron Tribe,Christopher Ryder,Jan Kleinert
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2017

High Throw DC Acid Copper Formulation for Vertical Continuous Electroplating Process

Member Download (pdf)

Electronics industry has grown immensely over the last few decades owing to the rapid growth of consumer electronics in the modern world. New formulations are essential to fit the needs of manufacturing printed circuit boards and semiconductors. Copper electrolytes for high throwing power applications with high thermal reliability and high throughput are becoming extremely important for manufacturing high aspect ratio circuit boards. Here we discuss innovative DC copper metallization formulations for hoist lines and VCP (Vertical Continues Plating) applications with high thermal reliability and throughput for high aspect ratio PCB manufacturing. The formula has a wide range of operation for current density. Most importantly plating at high current density using this DC high throw acid copper process offers high throughput,excellent thermal reliability,and improved properties for present-day PCB manufacturing. The operating CD range is 10 –30 ASF where microdistribution of = 85 % for AR 8:1 is achievable. This formulation offers bright ductile deposits were plating parameters are optimized for improved micro-distribution and the properties of the plated Cu deposit such as tensile strength and elongation. The Thermal reliability and properties of the deposits were examined at different bath ages. Measured properties are Elongation = 18% and tensile strength = 40,000 psi. All the additives can be easily controlled by CVS (Cyclic Voltammetric Stripping).

Author(s)
Saminda Dharmarathna Ph.D.,Ivan Li Ph.D.,Maddux Sy,Eileen Zeng,Bob Wei,William Bowerman,Kesheng Feng Ph.D.
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2017

Durable Conductive Inks and SMD Attachment for Robust Printed Electronics

Member Download (pdf)

Polymer Thick Film (PTF)-based printed electronics (aka Printed Electronics) has improved in durability over the last few decades and is now a proven alternative to copper circuitry in many applications once thought beyond the capability of PTF circuitry. This paper describes peak performance and areas for future improvement. State-of-the-art PTF circuitry performance includes the ability to withstand sharp crease tests,85C/85%RH damp heat 5VDC bias aging (silver migration),auto seat durability cycling,SMT mandrel flexing,and others. The IPC/SGIA subcommittee for Standards Tests development has adopted several ASTM test methods for PTF circuitry and is actively developing needed improvements or additions. These standards are described herein. Advantages of PTF circuitry over copper include: varied conductive material compositions,lower cost and lower environmental impact. Necessary improvements include: robust integration of chip and power,higher conductivity,and fine line multi-layer patterning.

Author(s)
Leonard Allison
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2017

Analysis of the Design Variables of Thermoforming Process on the Performance of Printed Electronic Traces

Member Download (pdf)

One specific market space of interest to emerging printed electronics is In Mold Label (IML) technology. IML is used in many consumer products and white good applications. When combined with electronics,the In Mold Electronics (IME) adds compelling new product functionality. Many of these products have multi-dimensional features and therefore require thermoforming processes in order to prepare the labels before they are in-molded. While thermoforming is not a novel technique for IML,the addition of printed electronic functional traces is not well documented. There is little or no published work on printed circuit performance and design interactions in the thermoforming process that could inform improved IME product designs. A general full factorial Design of Experiments (DOE) was used to analyze the electrical performance of the conductive silver ink trace/polycarbonate substrate system. Variables of interest include trace width,height of draw,and radii of both top and bottom curvatures in the draw area. Thermoforming tooling inserts were fabricated for eight treatment combinations of these variables. Each sample has one control and two formed strips. Electrical measurements were taken of the printed traces on the polymer sheets pre-and post-forming with a custom fixture to evaluate the effect on resistance. The design parameters found to be significant were draw height and bottom radius,with increased draw and smaller bottom curvature radii both contributing to the circuits’ resistance degradation. Over the ranges evaluated,the top curvature radii had no effect on circuit resistance. Interactions were present,demonstrating that circuit and thermoforming design parameters need to be studied as a system. While significant insight impacting product development was captured further work will be executed to evaluate different ink and substrate material sets,process variables,and their role in IME.

Author(s)
Gill M.,Gruner A.,Ghalib N.,Sussman M.,Avuthu S.,Wable G.,Richstein J. Jabil
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2017

3D Printed Electronics for Printed Circuit Structures

Member Download (pdf)

Printed electronics is a familiar term that is taking on more meaning as the technology matures. Flexible electronics is sometimes referred to as a subset of this and the printing approach is one of the enabling factors for roll to roll processes. Printed electronics is improving in performance and has many applications that compete directly with printed circuit boards. The advantage of roll to roll is the speed of manufacturing,the large areas possible,and a reduction in costs. As this technology continues to mature,it is also merging with the high profile 3D printing. 3D printing is becoming more than just a rapid prototyping tool and more than just printing small plastic toys. Companies are embracing 3D printing as a manufacturing approach to fabricate complex parts that cannot be done using traditional manufacturing techniques. The combination of 3D printing and printed electronics has the potential to make novel products and more specifically making objects electrically functional. Electrically functional objects have the advantage of competing with printed circuit boards. Printed circuit structures will be a new approach to electronic packaging. It is the desire of many companies to reduce assembly processes,decrease the size of the electronics,and do this at a reduced cost. This is challenging,but the potential of printing the structure and the electronics as a single monolithic unit has many advantages. This will reduce the human touch in assembly,as the electronics and the object are printed. This will increase the ruggedness of the product,as it is a monolithic device. This will eliminate wires,solder,and connectors,making the device smaller. This has the potential to be the future of printed circuit boards and microelectronic packaging. This paper will show working demonstrations of printed circuit structures,the obstacles,and the potential future of 3D printed electronics.

Author(s)
Samuel LeBlanc,Paul Deffenbaugh,Jacob Denkins,Kenneth Church
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2017

Assessing the Effectiveness of I/O Stencil Aperture Modifications on BTC Void Reduction

Member Download (pdf)

Bottom terminated components,or BTCs,have been rapidly incorporated into PCB designs because of their low cost,small footprint and overall reliability. The combination of leadless terminations with underside ground/thermal pads have presented a multitude of challenges to PCB assemblers,including tilting,poor solder fillet formation,difficult inspection and –most notably –center pad voiding. Voids in large SMT solder joints can be difficult to predict and control due to the variety of input variables that can influence their formation. Solder paste chemistries,PCB final finishes,and reflow profiles and atmospheres have all been scrutinized,and their effects well documented. Additionally,many of the published center pad voiding studies have focused on optimizing center pad footprint and stencil aperture designs. This study focuses on I/O pad stencil modifications rather than center pad modifications. It shows a no-cost,easily implemented I/O design guideline that can be deployed to consistently and repeatedly reduce void formation on BTC-style packages.

Author(s)
Carlos Tafoya,Gustavo Ramirez,Timothy O'Neill
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2017

Fill the Void II: An Investigation into Methods of Reducing Voiding

Member Download (pdf)

Voids in solder joints plague many electronics manufacturers. Do you have voids in your life? We have good news for you,there are many excellent ways to “Fill the Void.” This paper is a continuation of previous work on voiding in which the following variables were studied: water soluble lead-free solder pastes,a variety of stencil designs,and reflow profiles. Quad Flat No-Lead (QFN) component thermal pads were used as the test vehicle. The voiding results were summarized and recommendations were made for reduction of voiding. In this work several new variables and their effects on voiding were studied. No clean lead-free solder pastes were tested and compared to water soluble lead-free solder pastes. Water soluble solder pastes tend to create more voiding than no clean solder pastes. This is due to the relatively higher volatile content in water soluble solder pastes,and also due to the hygroscopic nature of water soluble solder pastes. The particle size of the solder powder was studied; using IPC type 3,IPC type 4 and IPC type 5 powders. The oxide content of the solder powder increases with decreasing particle size and higher oxide content tends to produce higher voiding levels. Different manufacturers of solder powder were also studied. Solder powder from one manufacturer might lead to higher voiding than from another manufacturer. Finally,the effects of convection reflow were compared to vapor phase reflow with and without vacuum. Convection reflow is commonly used and voiding results from this type of reflow are well documented. Vapor phase reflow is conducted in an oxygen free environment which tends to reduce voiding. Vapor phase systems also lend themselves well to the use of vacuum because the equipment is sealed and vapor tight. Integrating vacuum creates differential pressure between the void and the surrounding atmosphere during the liquid stage which facilitates the escape of the trapped gases. The lowering of the gas pressure outside the solder joints will aid in reduction of voiding. Reworking solder joints with voids is not an easy task. This typically involves removing the affected components and re-soldering them with the hope that voiding might be reduced. This is a very labor intensive process which can thermally stress nearby components. The possibility of using a vapor phase reflow system with vacuum to rework solder joints with voids was investigated. In many cases voiding will be reduced only if a combination of mitigation strategies are used. Recommendations for combinations of solder paste,stencil design,reflow profile,and type of reflow are given. The aim of this paper is to help the reader to “Fill the Void.”

Author(s)
Tony Lentz,Patty Chonis,JB Byers
Resource Type
Technical Paper
Event
IPC APEX EXPO 2017