Two independent Printed Circuit Board (PCB) suppliers found unusually high voiding anomalies in multiple manufacturing lots of PCBs that were processed over a 5 month period. The issue was noted during conformance coupon inspection of an initial lot, and subsequently determined to be isolated to the prepregnated portion of pure polyimide constructions in a number of PCB manufacturing lots. During the study, the team investigated numerous variables potentially associated with the root cause of the anomaly, including but not limited to: raw materials, conformance coupon preparation, and processing issues. The objective of this paper is to describe the approaches and techniques used in this void anomaly case history when requirements are not always clearly stated.
An initial review meeting was requested by one of the PCB suppliers and was attended by: the PCB manufacturer, procuring activity, design agent, and raw material manufacturer. The purpose of the meeting was to identify the anomalies, categorize them, and determine acceptability based on product specifications. Also addressed during the review were potential impacts to product functionality. The following categories were used for anomaly identification: glass tear out, void/striation, bundle cracks, foreign material, and unknown. The categorization was conducted to help the team determine the appropriate acceptability criteria for each attribute. A pareto analysis indicted that the top two anomalies observed were void/striation and glass tear out. In many cases, it was difficult to determine the difference between the two. A striation (or tunnel void) is a void in the resin between the filaments of the fiberglass bundle. A tear out is a condition where sections of glass bundles are removed from the potted coupon, as a result of coupon preparation (grinding and polishing). Based on MIL-PRF-31032/1 (2020), voids/striations are a rejectable condition if they are out of the thermal zone, and the condition is greater than .08 mm, and/or reduces the dielectric to below the minimum requirement. Upon further investigation, it was found that the anomalies were potentially related to the glass style used in the prepregnated layers.
This paper provides a methodical approach to investigating particular anomalies in PCBs to determine acceptability. It may be utilized as a guideline for others facing a similar anomalies associated with PCBs.